D_032 MEDIATHEKMELBOURNE

Hani Rashid . This project is a very strong attempt to reconcile digital tools with program and structure, and it works to a certain extent. However the complexity of the outcome and the simplicity of the premise seem to be at odds. It is interesting to note that our predigital radical architecture by the likes of Himmenblau and Hadid in the 80's had a similar outcome without a computer in sight. So for me the question remains, why cloak a complex, well executed building design like this in digital garb, or from another point of view, what did the tools allow this architect to achieve beyond shear complexity?

Brian Johnson . A certain amount of 'noise' accompanies some pretty strong content. Layout and sequence of presentation could be stronger...

Chris Sharples . It is a comprehensive proposal that will have an exciting impact on the Melbourne waterfront.

Mahesh Senagala . Eye candy. Good one at that! There is sufficient architectural rigor and a clear use of digital media from the beginning to the end. There is abundance of youthful exuberance! ...

Carmina Sanchez . Here is more of the scaffolding-like construction architecture. The web site design and detail of models and explanations are exceptional. All of that accounts for a big WOW factor. This is a project to learn from in terms of representation.